Category Archives: Ben Aaronovitch

Ben Aaronovitch: The Hanging Tree (Review)

Ben Aaronovitch's picture

Ben Aaronovitch
UK (1964 – )

Ben Denis Aaronovitch is a London-born British writer who has worked on television series including Doctor Who, Casualty, Jupiter Moon and Dark Knight. He is the younger brother of actor Owen Aaronovitch and British journalist David Aaronovitch.

Author Web site

book cover of The Hanging Tree

The Hanging Tree  (2016)
(The sixth book in the PC Peter Grant series)

Suspicious deaths are not usually the concern of PC Peter Grant or the Folly, even when they happen at an exclusive party in one of the most expensive apartment blocks in London. But Lady Ty’s daughter was there, and Peter owes Lady Ty a favour.

Plunged into the alien world of the super-rich, where the basements are bigger than the house and dangerous, arcane items are bought and sold on the open market, a sensible young copper would keep his head down and his nose clean. But this is Peter Grant we’re talking about.

He’s been given an unparalleled opportunity to alienate old friends and create new enemies at the point where the world of magic and that of privilege intersect. Assuming he survives the week….

Review

The Rivers / PC Grant series is in my opinion one of the best, most original and funny series i have read in the last 5 years, starting with Rivers of London it erupted into my reading world as a breath of fresh air and proceeded to wow until what i felt was a dip in book 4 Broken Homes. Fox Glove summer in 2014 was almost a return to form, but  with its escape from London it both lost some of its sparkle, but also gained some new expansiveness, but for all that i have still been an avid reader eager for each and every book.

The gap from then to the eagerly anticipated Hanging Tree, a book that seemed to not to want to come out has been longer than hoped for, but, it has finally ended and the book has arrived. The story/plot was everything i could have hoped for. Peter Grant is back to his funny sarcastic self, plodding through life shrugging off the spectacular events and turns his life takes with a casual nonchalance as if they were boring trips to the super market. The magical events/ escapades of spirits, gods and magic users of no more peculiarity than the average office job. Its this casual flippancy that gives the book its casual humour and still manages to build an exciting fast paced plot line often with dire consequences for property, life and limb.

As always when i read a Ben Aaronovitch i’m left with a feeling that the writer is just that bit smarter than the rest of us, he is Nightingale, the one who knows and see’s more than the rest of us, but can only impart what we are ready to see and learn.  Giving us a brilliantly complex and yet startling simple story of Good v Evil, Copper v Criminal…. but if you scratch away the veneer of civilization and look behind the scenes at the world of magic the author has created the complexities grow, the shades of grey expand and the series leaves you stunned at the hugely complex world that Ben Aaronovitch has devised….. I for one would like to see some of the side stories hinted at: EG the war tales of Nightingale and how he ends up at etterberg and what actually happened during Operation Spatchcock.

So The Hanging Tree… a return to form? For me a truly excellent book…. right up to the end…. because, there wasn’t an end… the book stopped, but for me the story hadn’t. It was like an advert break where the next part didn’t record, or a “To be continued” flashes up. To be honest made me think that what ever delayed the book may have been resolved, but i’m not sure the ending to this book had been, i wondered if it had been taken as … a good enough point to stop. This in a series/ book can sometimes be a personal thing, when the bad guy spans multiple books. But in this case, the bad guy is still free, the objective from the start of the book isn’t resolved and many of the little side tales/ elements that an author ties up with a nice bow.,.. well they are all left hanging… now it could be said that this is more real… but for a book it left me say flicking back and forth wondering where the next/ last chapter was…

a big shame what would have been a 5 star book becomes a 4 because there was no climax…. 😉 … however i will still be front and center for the next book… even more so with the unresolved ending…. maybe that’s the reason?? Leave them wanting more…

(Parm)

Series
PC Peter Grant
1. Rivers of London (2011)
aka Midnight Riot
2. Moon Over Soho (2011)
3. Whispers Under Ground (2012)
4. Broken Homes (2013)
5. Foxglove Summer (2014)
6. The Hanging Tree (2016)
P C Grant Novels (omnibus) (2013)
Ben Aaronovitch The PC Grant Novels 4 Books Collection Set, (omnibus) (2015)
The PC Grant Collection (2017)

Doctor Who Leather Bind-Up (with Trevor Baxendale)
Remembrance of the Daleks / Prisoner of the Daleks(2016)
Series contributed to
Doctor Who : Seventh Doctor
Remembrance of the Daleks (1990)
Doctor Who : New Adventures
10. Transit (1992)
44. The Also People (1995)
56. So Vile a Sin (1997) (with Kate Orman)
Professor Bernice Summerfield
Genius Loci (2007)

1 Comment

Filed under Ben Aaronovitch, Fantasy

Ben Aaronovitch Foxglove Summer (Review)

ben

 

Ben Denis Aaronovitch is a London-born British writer who has worked on television series including Doctor Who, Casualty, Jupiter Moon and Dark Knight. He is the younger brother of actor Owen Aaronovitch and British journalist David Aaronovitch.

Description

image_6

BUY A SIGNED COPY

In the fifth of his bestselling series Ben Aaronovitch takes Peter Grant out of whatever comfort zone he might have found and takes him out of London – to a small village in Herefordshire where the local police are reluctant to admit that there might be a supernatural element to the disappearance of some local children. But while you can take the London copper out of London you can’t take the London out of the copper.

Travelling west with Beverley Brook, Peter soon finds himself caught up in a deep mystery and having to tackle local cops and local gods. And what’s more all the shops are closed by 4pm

Review

I’m a big fan of this series, ever since the very first book its been utterly original, witty, clever and a riveting read. Foxglove Summer was the same and yet a different experience for me to a certain degree, the usual wit was there, and moving the story out of London added a new element, a different edge to the plot, and for much of the book i was utterly riveted, i had read the whole book in 2 nights (and given that’s just bed time reading that’s fast).

What threw me in the book was that it didn’t feel like it had the same complexity and depth that the previous books have had. despite Peter being allowed off the leash by Nightingale, and that Beverly is there leading him astray again, and Lesley is poking her nose in at the wings, I still felt that there was a layer a dimension to the complexity that was missing, an element of that clever wordsmith(erey) that the author portrays in this series that just didn’t feel like it was there.  And the bit that really let me down was the ending, lt felt like the end of an episode left unfinished in a TV series, the final chapter rushed to a conclusion as if there was a need to finish by a specific date or word count rather than complete the story. But despite that im still left in awe of the writers skill, with so many questions i would like to ask, and hope will be answered in the next book, and there are so many teasers for the world of the fae and the world of magic, we have still only just taken the top layer off, each book giving a little bit more of a glimpse and that’s the beauty of reading the story through Peter Grants eyes, we learn as he learns.

If this was any other author and any other series this would get a 3/5, but a ruined ending does not ruin the story, the incredible characters, the totally original plot line and depth of imagination the author displays. so 4/5 and i hope book 6 is solid all the way to a full conclusion.

a series i will always recommend

(Parm)

 

Series

 

Peter Grant
1. Rivers of London (2011)
aka Midnight Riot
2. Moon Over Soho (2011)
3. Whispers Under Ground (2012)
4. Broken Homes (2013)
5. Foxglove Summer (2014)
6. The Hanging Tree (2015)
P C Grant Novels: Rivers of London / Moon Over Soho / Whispers Under Ground (omnibus) (2013)
Rivers of LondonMoon Over SohoWhispers Under GroundBroken HomesFoxglove Summer
P C Grant Novels: Rivers of London / Moon Over Soho / Whispers Under Ground

 

Leave a comment

Filed under Ben Aaronovitch, Crime, Fantasy, Supernatural